I’m a fan of both James Patterson and Mike Lupica since thrillers and sports are two of my favorite genres. Surprisingly, what stood out most to me in The Country Road Murders was the main character, Silas. Athletic, thoughtful and caring despite a difficult upbringing, he reminded me of some of my former students. He is the kind of young person whose toughness is easy to see, but whose heart is what you remember.

4/5 stars ★★★★☆
Click to read the summary or to buy on Amazon
Genre: Mystery / Thriller / Sports / Fiction
Pages: 416
Published on: July 13, 2026
📚 Judi’s Report Card on The Country Road Murders:
Main Character: A ❤️🏈
Silas was the strongest part of the book for me. I love how he treated his grandmother and best friends.
Supporting Characters: B+ 👥
The supporting cast added heart and helped show different sides of Silas, although a few characters could have been developed more.
Writing: A- ✍️📖
Patterson and Lupica kept the story readable and engaging, with clear writing, natural dialogue, and short chapters that moved quickly.
Mystery & Suspense: B 🔍🚨
There wasn’t a lot of mystery to the story. The characters were ultimately more memorable to me than the investigation itself.
Pacing: B ⏱️
Most of the story moved along quickly. I especially liked the football parts of the storyline.
Overall Grade: B ⭐⭐⭐⭐
I enjoyed the story, especially the characterization. There wasn’t enough mystery/thriller for me, but it was still a fun read.
My Thoughts on The Country Road Murders:
Blend of Genres:
One of the reasons that I like when Patterson teams up with Lupica is because there is always a blend of genres. With Lupica, you know you are going to get a strong sports background to the story. The football element felt realistic and added to the story.
With Patterson, you know you are going to get shorter chapters with some mystery. There was also the small-town feeling, family secrets, romance, friendship, and organized crime.
Characterization:
The characterization was the strength of the book. I like that there were so many sides to Silas. His character was well-developed, and I never stopped cheering him on. His relationship with Taylor, his best friend since elementary school, and his grandmother, EJ, showed Silas’ soft, caring side. His drive to take out his opponents on the field and the Southern Mafia off the field showed his grit and determination. Since EJ raised Silas since he was fourteen, you can tell where he got his determination from throughout the years.
There were a lot of supporting characters, so you couldn’t dive into them as much, but EJ and Taylor were my two favorites. Their love for Silas showed no boundaries, especially while he was struggling.
My Rating:
Overall, The Country Road Murders is worth reading, as long as you do not expect an intense mystery or thriller. If you like small-town stories, sports, and a cast that includes loyal friends, strong family figures, and determined underdogs, then you will enjoy this book.
Where to Buy The Country Road Murders and More:
- Read more of my book reviews: Visit my library
- Missed my Top Books of 2025? Check out the full list here
📝 Extra Credit Reading:
If The Country Road Murders earned a passing grade from you, add these three books to your extra-credit reading list:
- A Dead Draw by Robert Dugoni | Buy on Amazon
- Read my full review here
- Why? Like The Country Road Murders, this book combines a compelling mystery with characters you genuinely care about. Both stories feature thoughtful, capable characters who are driven by loyalty and a strong sense of justice.
- Beach Thriller by Jamie Day | Buy on Amazon
- Read my full review here
- Why? Although the setting and main characters are very different, Beach Thriller is another character-driven mystery in which grief, family history, and old secrets are just as important as the suspense.
- Lies He Told Me by James Patterson and David Ellis | Buy on Amazon
- Read my full review here
- Why? Like The Country Road Murders, it features Patterson’s fast pace and the characters are forced to uncover painful truths about the people closest to them.
Disclosure: Thank you to NetGalley, Little, Brown & Co, James Patterson and Mike Lupica for my free copy of this book. This is my honest opinion.
💬 Let’s Chat:
Have you ever read a character who reminded you of someone you once taught, worked with, or knew in real life?














